True Fet
Sign up free
IR

Safety & Consent

Negotiation checklists: how do you guys actually use them??

Posted Oct 13, 2026

Replies5
IR
IronWardenOriginal Poster
Oct 13, 2026

Sorry if this is the wrong spot lol. I think this one is actually the right spot for once??

So I found the big yes/no/maybe list everyone passes around, like 200 items. To me it reads like a session zero sheet, lines and veils basically. My plan for whenever I get there: both people fill it out separately, compare, then talk through anything that doesn't match.

Questions:
Is that how people actually use it or is that overkill??
Do you redo it every time or once and done?
What's on it that people skip and shouldn't?

Also update, I found the reading. Thank you to whoever finally told me WHICH pinned post πŸ˜…

ReactReplySubscribe

Replies

  • AL
    Oct 13, 2026

    quoting: "both people fill it out separately, compare, then talk"

    counterpoint: 200-item checklists are mostly theater πŸ™‚ you end up agreeing about item 147 and never saying the stuff that matters. what scares you. what you do when you're scared. how i'll know 🫠

    still have the conversation. the list isn't the conversation πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ

    not personal πŸ™‚

    ReactReply
  • CH
    Oct 13, 2026

    ngl I like the big list. not bc it's magic, bc it makes the boring talk happen before anybody's in the mood to skip it. negotiation isnt the vibe killer, getting surprised is

    @albedo yeah the list isnt the convo but it's how i start one with somebody whose whole plan was gonna be 'so how much can you take' lol. masochist does not mean no limits. I have a whole list. it's not laminated. it should be

    warden your plan is fine. do the talking part over coffee not over text πŸ™ƒ

    β€” mags

    ReactReply
  • MA
    Oct 13, 2026

    Quoting: "Do you redo it every time or once and done?"

    That's the real question in this thread, so let me steelman albedo first and then disagree with nearly everyone.

    1. albedo is right that a list can replace the conversation instead of starting it. I've watched it happen. Two people agree on 140 items and never mention the one thing that would actually have mattered on the night.
    2. Mags and zug are right that a list surfaces things a nervous person won't think to say. Also real.
    3. Where I part ways with all of you: every version of this treats negotiation as something that ends before the scene starts. A checklist is a snapshot. A safeword is a word someone may not be able to say when it counts. Check-ins are the part that keeps negotiating after the list goes back in the drawer, and they get a fraction of the airtime.

    So, Warden, list or no list: plan your check-ins as carefully as your yes/no/maybe. How often, what they sound like, and what a non-answer means.

    Happy to be wrong. πŸ€”

    ReactReply
  • TY
    Oct 13, 2026

    Both. (Mostly list.)

    New dom to new dom, Warden: the list is the boring part and the boring part is the job. You carry the snacks, the scissors and the boring converstion. Every time. Going through 200 items together is slow and ugly and it tells you who's patient before anything starts. Measure twice.

    albedo's not wrong that people hide behind it. So don't. Fill it out, then sit there and ask the dumb follow-up on every maybe. And redo it every time. Wood moves. People move more. 🦑

    ReactReply
  • IR
    IronWardenOriginal Poster
    Oct 13, 2026

    Okay so the answer is list AND conversation AND check-ins, every time. Honestly albedo and ChromeMagpie both have a point, which seems to be how every thread on here ends lol

    Still keeping the list though. Session zero without a sheet is how my last campaign ended up with a surprise spider dungeon and a player who is terrified of spiders. Never again.

    @Marginalia planning the check-ins like that is lowkey the thing I didn't know to ask. Writing it down. Rolling with it. 🎲

    ReactReply